MMoexp: Your three Diamond picks are the backbone of MLB 25 Stubs your team. That means you should never waste them on pitchers, even if you're offered an elite 99-rated arm.
Why? Simple: pitchers can't appear in every game. Due to stamina constraints, even top-tier starters will only be usable once every few games. Meanwhile, a Diamond position player hits your lineup every time, making their impact consistent and immediate.
So when you're staring down that tempting 99 Roger Clemens card, resist. Go for sluggers or all-around hitters who can change the game at the plate instead.
Prioritize Pitchers With Sinker/Cutter Mixes
While Diamonds shouldn't be used on pitchers, your lower-rated rounds (Bronze, Silver, and possibly one Gold) are the perfect time to build a deceptively strong rotation and bullpen.
Focus less on ratings and more on pitch mix. Target arms that throw sinkers, cutters, or have outlier fastballs. These pitches disrupt timing and reduce the chances of giving up moonshots, a constant risk in BR's home-run-heavy gameplay.
If your offense is already locked in, it's okay to spend a Gold pick on cheap MLB The Show 25 Stubs a lockdown reliever. Just don't overdo it, BR is all about offense.